This is an excerpt from the documentary, “Why We Fight”
Now that the Sopranos, Rome, and Deadwood are all kaput, HBO seems to be left with very little to attract & keep a big subscriber base. The biggest blunder? John From Cincinnati, David Milch’s sophomore HBO entry, second to his marvelous Deadwood.
Now that we have two shows from the same creative mind, we can contrast & compare and the conclusion is less than favorable. Milch’s penchant for the examination of the mundane seemed to work well for Deadwood, a story set in 1877, where even the mundane was interesting. But in a contemporary setting, the show itself is mundane. In each episode, there is at least one scene that features a majority of characters just standing around like some damned tableau, each performing a trivial task that makes the thinnest attempt to move the plot forward.
John From Cincinnati takes the route of showing us something bizarre and nonsensical and leaving it up to the audience to assign importance or relevance. Is that really my job, though? And who the hell chose that toe-headed surfer punk to be one of the main characters? The tragedy is that even if this kid could act, it wouldn’t save the show. The one good thing about the show is the opening theme by one of my favorites, Joe Strummer. I’m always disappointed when the theme song is over and the actual program begins.
The other new show is The Flight of the Conchords, featuring the New Zealand comedy musical duo of the same name. This is a show that my brother was moved by to the point of calling me and essentially demanding that I watch. The show resembles one that I might like but for some reason, I do not. I think it’s the breaking into song that’s the most troubling for me but since it’s the main premise of the show, very little can be done. I have the same hurdle to jump when I watch musicals and for this reason, I do not watch them.
What about Big Love? Sure, it’s groundbreaking subject matter: polygamy, one that I do not believe has been covered in any motion picture medium before but the bottom line is that I’m just not interested in it. Entourage is the only decent show in the roster and that may not be good enough. So HBO had better get their shit together if they’re expected to make it.
Showtime, on the other hand, seems to be going in the direction of HBO by offering more and more original programming. Weeds and Sleeper Cell are both wonderful! Dexter is good, not great. I’ve only seen the pilot episode of The Tudors, which was also good but not great.