This story about why award shows suck got me thinking. Here’s the bit that did it…
There’s a huge gap between what the public prefers and what creative institutions honor. For example, “Shrek 2″ gobbled up the most box office sales in 2004, but it wasn’t nominated for best picture at the Oscars or Globes, although it did receive animation award nods. Other snubs went to box-office champs “The Passion of the Christ,” “Fahrenheit 9/11″ and “Spider-Man.”
I don’t disagree there’s a gap but let’s ask the big question…why is there a gap? Why are popular films (by and large) not received well by the critics?
Well basically, critics still think of film as an art form. Granted, it’s probably the most accessible art form we have which accounts for this supposed disparity. I tend to think of film as an art form, too. I like how effective a film can be at getting me to think about issues I might not normally think about. A film might show me a facet of the human condition in a way I hadn’t seen before. Shrek 2, while entertaining, doesn’t aspire to such peaks. Nor does Spider Man.
Some people might say, “Who the fuck cares about the human condition? I just want to be entertained.” That’s all fine and good but entertainment is not the end-all, be-all for cinema. Film can do so much more than merely entertain. If entertainment was the only reason we did things, we wouldn’t need movies. Monster Truck shows and Professional Wrestling is entertainment to millions of people. They don’t make movies out of it, though. That stuff is for TV.
My taste? I’m probably somewhere in the middle. I can have a profoud admiration for films like Taxi Driver and Do the Right Thing and at the same time, enjoy popcorn flicks like Starship Troopers and Independence Day. My favorite films generally do not make a lot of money nor do they appear on lists like the Top Grossing Films of All Time, so I probably contribute to “the gap.”
Award shows like the Oscars are not there to celebrate the biggest money makers (by definition, the most popular). Being a big money maker is it’s own reward. No, the Oscars celebrate film excellence they way they’ve always done. The way all award shows do, be it Grammys, Tonys, or Emmys. The Oscars might not always be accurate but the intent is clearly to recognize those films that transcend the art form. For the most part, the Oscars have done this well.
Movies, Television | No Comments »